Home > Fail > As if we needed another reason to love Yelp….

As if we needed another reason to love Yelp….

May 27, 2009 12 Comments »

What a lovely fail to wake up to in my inbox…

128879122746916567jpg1

To be perfectly clear, when I contacted the staff at SF Women Against Rape to let them know about what they were have purported to have sponsored, they were unaware that their name had been used in conjunction with such a horrifically flawed attempt at crafting a catchy, clever, innuendo-filled headline.

This is the last straw in what I find to be a pattern of shortsightedness regarding user privacy and safety, questionable sales tactics, and generally tasteless conduct on the part of yelp hq, and as of today, I’m removing all of my “useful” content – I’m not willing to contribute to padding the wallets of anyone who thinks nothing of pairing innuendo with sexual assault.


Update:

Keep in mind that not only did yelp send out this message, but their flawed user privacy practices – including completely violating the contract that only your first name and last initial were to be exposed – allowed at least four people I *know*, including myself, to be stalked, some receiving death threats, people showing up at their places of employment, etc.

And had I known that someone who once tried to strangle me and run me over would be able to find me out of the other hundreds of people with my first name and last initial on yelp, so that they could move across the country and into my neighborhood, start showing up at my morning coffee shop, on my train, and following me to my house, I would have never written those reviews.

But thanks to their misrepresentation of their privacy policy, I did – and he did.

That’s what made the content of this ‘newsletter’ the last straw.


Yelp, it was fun while it lasted, but your head just got too big to see what’s really going on. And yes, that’s what tends happen when you only think about what’s going on between your legs.

No related posts.

Bookmark and Share
Tags:

Comments:8

Leave my own
  1. Jan
    May 27, 2009 at 6:40 pm

    Good job on highlighting that sentence to make it look like Yelp! is saying that they sometimes ride in and put some fun between our legs… :P

    http://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/business/Yelps-Humor-Offends-Women-Everywhere.html#qZg1YogiiGpEZGIGHK944xDvEuhdl460nuSwLmdd4G9eSDrD61mCVVvPlVIxPydACDmj21910Ie6XpnxVs18B

    Now that’s what the Bay Area News is reporting. I suppose that it is his/her fault for not reading the original un-highlighted email…

    I’ve commented on the article … told them Shame on THEM for their own error. It might be changed (and my comment will remain unposted) by the time you see it, but I’ve taken a screen shot of it so you can:

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/jannygirl/3572190066/in/photostream/

  2. soychicka
    May 27, 2009 at 8:24 pm

    I can assure you that my intent in highlighting the portion of the sentence which reads “we sometimes ride in and put some fun between your legs” WAS IN NO WAY an attempt to be humorous. Even though the context depicted above may not have been the statement the author intended to make, the first 5 times I read that email, those were the words which popped out at me. And as anyone who works in communications ought to know, you must be able to ensure that every potential combination of words pulled out from an official communication, even those which may be out of context, must be beyond reproach.

    And this is not an isolated incident. The ‘Weekly Yelp’ has arrived in my inbox with such clever subjects as ‘Yelp Smokes the Meat,’ ‘Yelp’s A Cheap Date,’ and, of course, multiple times, ‘Make Me Yelp,’ and filled with innuendo that often border on the cusp of being excessively gratutious. And face it – the reason they do it is because it works: piques our interest, it gets us to open the emails, and draws interest to their site.

    But when that’s the game you’re playing, you mustn’t take it too far… you must ensure that you don’t cross the line from being risque to being offensive and triggering an emotional response in someone who may have been the victim of sexual assault. Even if the sponsor of this particular mailing was not SF Women Against Rape – a very worthy, very professional organization, I might add, who should bear none of the blame in this matter – I would have found that it crossed that boundary.

    Yelp needs to learn that if you’re mass communicating, you need to know how to play the game. Because in that world, intent means nothing. Perception is reality.

  3. brendan
    May 28, 2009 at 6:06 am

    you should go. no ill intent at all in this coincidence.

  4. bulshoy
    May 28, 2009 at 6:53 am

    Why is sexual innuendo inappropriate? Why would such a thing cause trauma to a rape victim? Do you consider all sex to be rape?

    Such people (those offended) must live in a closed environment with no TV, radio, newspapers, magazines, books or windows, because sexual innuendo is everywhere. The vast majority are not offended (in fact some find it quite humorous). Why should Yelp capitulate to the very, very few who might be offended? Should every aspect of life be sanitized to avoid the possibility of offending someone?

  5. Katie
    May 29, 2009 at 3:33 pm

    This is just more proof that yelp is run by a bunch of incompetent buffoons. Yelp and their hard core followers (those that insist you just shut up and ignore any mistakes that yelp makes) are the same type of people who will insist that a woman “was asking for it” because she wore a revealing outfit on the day she was raped. Yelp has no problem hounding local organizations for advertising dollars, but they make absolutely no effort to ensure that the paying organization is given due respect. Frankly, I’m surprised that anybody is still sponsoring yelp. We already know that they extort money from small business owners, and now we know that they just slap sponsor names on newsletters without giving any consideration whatsoever to whether or not the content matches the sponsor. Yelp is a disgusting organization.

  6. Dave R.
    May 29, 2009 at 3:50 pm

    I think this is an IQ test. If you find yourself trying to justify why yelp’s actions are excusable or funny, then you failed the IQ test. If, on the other hand, you realize that sexual innuendos are NEVER appropriate in an advertisement for a sexual assault support organization, then you have some semblance of intelligence and you pass the IQ test.

  7. Funklord
    May 29, 2009 at 4:35 pm

    While I am not going to detract or defend soychicka’s argument, against Yelp!, I can personally attest to her NOT being a prude at all. For her, “Sucking the fun out” takes on a whole new meaning. I hope this clears up her character, and lets keep the comments about the arguments, and stay away from Ad Hominem

  8. soychicka
    May 29, 2009 at 5:14 pm

    @”sane” voice: you’re funny. (note: comment removed due to its tasteless and totally inaccurate nature. I don’t support slander).

    @funklord: you know my mom reads this, right? Looks like I need to get the funk out of you too :)

    and @the rest of the dissenters: you do realize that I was an active member of yelp for years, and lived on the talk threads for ages, right? I have very little problem with innuendo – but only when the innuendo comes from somewhere I’m interested in receiving it from. And I do not wish to receive that kind of innuendo from a profit-seeking corporate entity.

    Gentlemen, next time you’re walking down the street and see a woman with a bicycle, ask her if she’ll “put a little fun between your legs” and see how she reacts. (Oh god, I can just hear them saying this at the Matrix Fillmore now….)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackbacks:4

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference As if we needed another reason to love Yelp….

pingback from Yelp Sorry About Ruining Anti-Rape Message [Badvertising] | Breaking News | Latest News | Current News May 27, 2009

[...] furious blogger promised to draw her contributions to the user-review site, adding: I’m not selection to [...]

pingback from Yelp Sorry About Ruining Anti-Rape Message | Tech-monkey.info Blogs May 27, 2009

[...] furious blogger promised to yank her contributions to the user-review site, adding: I’m not willing to [...]

pingback from Yelp Sorry About Ruining Anti-Rape Message May 27, 2009

[...] furious blogger promised to yank her contributions to the user-review site, adding: I’m not willing to [...]

pingback from Yelp Sorry About Ruining Anti-Rape Message | Defamer Australia May 28, 2009

[...] furious blogger promised to yank her contributions to the user-review site, adding: I’m not willing to [...]